www.makemkv.com

^ I'm not sure what your goal is with these long stories that are filled with completely unrelated details. Why are you looking back to a rip you made in 2019? We already know that MakeMKV's previous approach for Atmos could have issues on some titles. You should make a new rip with 1.15.4 and if y...

I was just checking a MKV I created in 2019 from Karate Kid (1984) UHD/4K. This one has as first track Dolby Atmos, and then DD 5.1 derived from it (MAKEMKV saves the MKV file with both). It also has other english tracks, as described here: http://dvdcompare.net/comparisons/film.php?fid=50362 Since ...

This sheds a little light on what I've been experiencing. I don't know about anyone else but I'm getting tired of watching return of the jedi. All of my equipment is in another room so everyone else may already know this but when I get audio drop out or mute my AVP looses its sync on the atmos audi...

Update: warnings are still there for Beverly Hills Cop (1984) UHD. In this case I don't know if it's a false alert, don't notice anything wrong so far.

It looks like nothing will change for BTTF part I if I try again...

I just saw Mike has released a new MAKEMKV version: ********** MakeMKV v1.15.4 (8.12.2020 ) Improved handling for discs with mastering errors Many internal improvements and small bugfixes Implemented seamless joining of TrueHD streams with overlapping frames based on Dominik Mydlil's idea MakeMKV no...

https://makemkv.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=23937 I'll repeat what I said there here, in case I am not making myself clear: Even if this is a false alert for 90% of titles, it's also a problem. Why? I'll explain: When I ripped BTTF part I which has the Atmos track, there was no way to fix thi...

Even if this is a false alert for 90% of titles, it's also a problem. Why? I'll explain: When I ripped BTTF part I which has the Atmos track, there was no way to fix this. Apparently the only solution was to let all other tracks in the MKV file, including the DD 5.1 derived from Atmos. If I do that ...

More issues. This time with a UHD/4K that doesn't even have Atmos, only DTS-HD MA: http://dvdcompare.net/comparisons/film.php?fid=55853 Beverly Hills Cop, 1984. Recent release. Here's the log: https://pastebin.com/inUTrpxK It's really sad how these problems are pilling up. Either MAKEMKV has a lot o...

I didn't want to pay full price for the trilogy (AUD$89.00) so waited for a sale. Picked it up this morning at JB Hi-Fi @ 30% off so only paid AUD$62.30!! Happy camper! I have now just finished ripping them all. No issues at all. So no MAKEMKV warnings at all? For any disc? Can you post any log? Fo...

As you can see, this is a widespread issue. Another unrelated title, Total Recall (1990) in UHD/4K, showed the same warning. And once again it's not saying when this A/V sync issue happens, only that is there, read the log. And this title also has one Atmos track. But now please note more than one t...

https://i.postimg.cc/wBhM8jMV/XASA.png As you can see, it says A/V sync issue and nothing more... so if the audio commentaries had a problem, then why still the warning? New log: https://pastebin.com/JPyt9drx and attached. Well, I'll be waiting for a fix, because this is a deeper problem. What was ...

AV sync issues can occur whenever the playlist consists of multiple segments, but... Following your tips I created a log while attempting to rip BTTF part 2 again. The file is short, yet the messages now reveal more about this issue. I have attached here what it says, and you can also read here: ht...

So, any updates on this? Can someone at least confirm if this is a bug from MAKEMKV, a problem handling the discs perhaps due to a stronger protection (?) or they are all defective? Or perhaps a great number of discs are spoiled, and others are OK? Other users also had problems with this BTTF UHD b...

So, any updates on this? Can someone at least confirm if this is a bug from MAKEMKV, a problem handling the discs perhaps due to a stronger protection (?) or they are all defective? Or perhaps a great number of discs are spoiled, and others are OK? Other users also had problems with this BTTF UHD bo...

Any ideas? Should I just return it for a replacement? Is this problem only affecting MAKEMKV or did you notice any freezing after 40 minutes, for example, while watching? Because if these problems are only happening due to a MAKEMKV bug or problem reading them, then you can't return for replacement...